I liked Irrational Arousal but you got to admit it is a funky quirky story. Not everyone is going to go along with the world you built. I did and I'm glad.
Read the review and your comment back on SBTB today. Just wanted to say chin up (and don't eat ALL the cookies) and way to be classy about it. The reviews are funny as hell, but I'm well aware there's a human being taking the hits while everybody else is laughing. You're a good sport, all the best. Trish
Linked over from SBTB to drop a line and tell you that you ROCK. I cannot think of a funnier, classier way to respond to a negative review. Makes me want to buy a book of yours...and I'm not a romance reader! Plus, I see you're a Wodehouse fan. Also makes me want to pick up a book of yours.
I thought the premise of the book was really fresh and interesting and your good sportsmanship and sense of humor sold at least one book today.
I've cut out bits here and there but the gist is there. I don't want to cut too much because she's a good writer (other than the actual thinking/tolerance part) and it's bad idea to ignore that fact. . . . romance isn't about just any "two people" celebrating "love in its many forms." Organizations such as the Man-Boy Love Association would certainly refer to themselves as celebrating love "two people" (or more) finding love in one of its many forms" . . . while they actively promote pedophilia. Think RWA can't go down that slipper slope? Think again. Under our present definition, we cannot exclude such "love stories" under the category of "romance". We, as a culture, seem to have forgotten how to say "enough is enough," but RWA can--indeed, must--do better than that. . . . And, please, spare us the arguments about "censorship" and "inclusiveness." Preference for "one man,...
A two star Amazon review on His American Detective: "Bodice ripper about gay men by a woman." and I'm longing to comment "don't you mean a waistcoat ripper?" God, no. Stop me. The reviews rarely rattle me any longer -- except when I spot a truth in a bad one. When that happens, I actually lose sleep. This means I still care about writing. Speaking of reviewers and writers: A couple of days ago, a writer said she was tired of getting white ladies writing reviews of her books. She had an excellent point in the long run: her stories are meant for a particular audience and she wants them to resonate with those people and get more reviews from them. But that first line was just....horribly obnoxious. I say this from my POV of course. Not a white lady who writes reviews -- but as a review grubber. Anyone who disses any reader (especially ones that give honest reviews) deserves to be cast into the pit of being ignored. ...
I changed the title. I keep changing the contents because I keep changing my mind. Sue me. Karen is doing a interesting bunch of interviews and discussion about AA Romance at her blog . I keep weighing in, though it's clear to me that I should keep my mouth shut. I was blathering along about how I don't judge by genre, and I look for books by writers I like or that have good reviews when I suddenly realized that I haven't read that many reviews for AA books. hmmm Is that because they're there and I just skip over them? Where are those reviews? Well, well. Could I be a closet racist after all? (I'm always looking for signs. Got to stay on top of this sort of thing.) I know some people see AAs like inspirationals, which has its audience built into its genre**. I can't help it, I see a kind of "keep out" sign with inspies. [edited to remove small rant about inspies that has nothing to do with my point] I see it as a club for Christians and there's no...
You are an excellent rioter. I'd go to one of your riots any time.
ReplyDeleteAlso you *are* a riot.
I liked Irrational Arousal but you got to admit it is a funky quirky story. Not everyone is going to go along with the world you built. I did and I'm glad.
ReplyDeleteLisa R
Pick up your signs, Elsewhere! Today's riot is all about healthcare. OHHHH that's right. You don't have to care about that any more, do you!
ReplyDeleteLisa, thanks! Glad you liked the story. I had a lot of fun writing it.
Read the review and your comment back on SBTB today. Just wanted to say chin up (and don't eat ALL the cookies) and way to be classy about it. The reviews are funny as hell, but I'm well aware there's a human being taking the hits while everybody else is laughing. You're a good sport, all the best.
ReplyDeleteTrish
Thanks, Trish.
ReplyDeleteIt means a lot to me that you took the time to come over and comment.
Hey!
ReplyDeleteLinked over from SBTB to drop a line and tell you that you ROCK. I cannot think of a funnier, classier way to respond to a negative review. Makes me want to buy a book of yours...and I'm not a romance reader! Plus, I see you're a Wodehouse fan. Also makes me want to pick up a book of yours.
I thought the premise of the book was really fresh and interesting and your good sportsmanship and sense of humor sold at least one book today.
Cheers,
Laurel
Laurel? You rock. Thanks.
ReplyDelete